not tool but incredible

Review Score: (10/10)
being a tool fan and the judith track release being as it is, i did expect a more toolish album. On the fist listen it is a bit more mellow than tool, but its music and lyrics are top notch and the more i heard it the more i appreciated it. It is not by any means a lame side project or a carbon copy of tool it stands on its own merits and above most music out there and is worth picking up.

More Reviews:

• Great CD no matter what mood you're in.
• A classic for our generation
• Re Maynard: Drop the baggage
• Definately worthy of a 5-star review
• A whirlwind of provocative emotion stirs in this album
• Tool for wussies!!
• Best Cd I have ever purchased
• It's Dark, Creepy, Sexual, And Overwhelming
• Brilliant brilliant brilliant
• Brooding Brilliance
• Not as good as Tool's music
• Put a wicked smile on my face
• Second Best Debuet Album Ever Behind Undertow
• Very good.
• A Great Album
• purple monkey dishwasher
• An amazing journey
• Beautiful
• incredible...
• One of the best albums ever made
• Great Debut Album
• Great CD!!
• good stuff
• Great CD!!!
• morose & moody
• Hard to grade
• Not Tool but just as good!
• The Sound Can Never Be Replicated
• Yawn.....
• flawless - buy it now....
• incredible
• Great Album
• Unique; Not Tool
• Tool has more synergy !!
• wow
• Sell your soul, a dollar at a time
• Another one For IUKE wORLE
• Never heard Tool, but I like this.
• Sadly its no Tool...
• step into the hollow
• Suprisingly different from Tool.
• A Perfect Circle's debut, not bad at all
• APC
• It's Maynard. Do I really have to say anything else?
• Mer de Not Just Another Tool Album
• sea of names ( i think it means that? )
• For IUKE wORLE
• Brilliant Cd
• Becoming one of my Favorites
• One of the Best CDs ever!
• Music good:) message bad:(
• There is no better CD...
• If I had to choose a list of my most favorite CDs...
• Their circle is not perfect.
• Mer de Noms - A True Statement
• Thank God!!
• absolutely irresistible!!!!
• One of THE most gorgeous rock albums ever
• Gothic atmosphere,Heavy sound,great melodies
• good album
• El Perfecto Melodrama convertido en música
• It ain't tool, but is that necessarily bad?
• So perfect
• Simply amazing music
• its a true perfect circle
• Good (but not Tool good)
• A Perfect Album!!!
• I can't say enough good...
• The Umbilical Residue Keeping me From Killing You- and More!
• wow.....
• One of the Best CDs I've ever owned...PERIOD
• Aural Beauty...
• Something coming from many places
• Oh, no.
• The Best Release of 2000
• this cd comes full circle...
• this should be 10 stars
• Not to be compared to Tool
• Excellent.
• Dark
• Greatest Band in the world
• pure beauty
• Incredible amazing to no end
• A Perfect CD
• unmatched
• Don't compare it to Tool
• Everything Maynerd touches i cherish !
• Superb
• The most perfect band ever
• A Beautiful Album
• Maynard shows that he's human.
• GREAT BEAUTIFUL MUSIC
• PERFECT
• Mer de Noms [INEXPLICIT LYRICS]
• Hey, who is this guy Billy Howerdel anyway?
• A New Definition For Modern Rock
• Passionate music is still around
• A great side project worthy of Maynard's talent
• Not exactly Tool, still brilliant.
• Mer de Noms: Tre Bon