Not "Garbage" just trash
Review Score: 








(2/10)
I tried as hard as I could to like this CD, but have failed. Garbage self titled was an amazing rock CD with a decidedly dark, sometimes vunerable, core. Their follow up Version 2.0 is a CD you can listen to like once a day and never get sick of. So when Beautiful Garbage came out I bought a copy expecting the same brilliance, I should have listened to it before buying it, by the second track I wasn't sure if it was the right band!
I'm not a person who criticizes bands for taking up a new direction, but I hate it when a good band totaly sells out and there is no other way of explaining this CD. The songs are all boring pop music that is obviously a grab at the profitable comercially driven music market.
This CD will ultimately backfire on the band as they cannot hope to gain as many fans as they will lose with this CD, as they already have an established 'look' and will never crack the mainstream market like the Britney Spears/Backstreet boys type fare that dominates the charts.
The one star rating was for the song Cherry Lips because it has a quirky quality that like most novelties quickly wheres off. The rest of the tracks are complete throw-aways.
As far as I can imagine, the members of the band were kidnapped by forces unknown and replaced by corporate clones that released this souless pop CD under the guise of "Beautiful". Hopefully the Garbage we know and love will be returned soon.
More Reviews:
- Smelly garbage
- Garbage sounds like No Doubt...Why Oh Why
- Not Quite As Good As Their Other Albums, and yet....
- Beautiful Garbage - you might just want to skip this one!
- Great stuff from a diverse band
- Once again.... Beautiful Garbage Brilliant
- New and old come together for a party of something unique
- Incredibly catchy
- A VERY Noticable Change
- Garbage Does It Again
- Garbage's best work yet
- Not Beautiful at All
- Beautifulgarbage indeed.
- Not their best
- Beautiful, not garbage
- Grabage Reemerge
- Beautiful enough, but I miss the darkness
- pretty good
- ohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh doctor...
- WOW! One of the best CDs EVER!
- Garbage no more...
- Great Album
- I love this CD because...
- Beautifulgarbage Rules
- Nothing Special Here
- These guys (and gal) can do it all
- Garbage has never sounded more beautiful.
- Garbage by name, not by nature
- Are you REALLY a Garbage fan?
- Old Garbage fans will be disapointed
- Evolution of Garbage
- The very definition of a mixed bag
- Not beautiful, but pretty
- One of the BEST CD's ever, yet unjusly ignored.
- A decline, but not the end of the world
- Yuck...
- Version 3.0 It Is Not
- More then Just Beautiful Grabage
- Evolution? not for the better
- Third album, third masterpiece
- A huge let down
- Garbage is the Best
- Third time's a charm
- Garbage made it Beautiful!!
- better than the first 2
- Don't Bother
- solid follow-up record
- Yeah man... Five stars
- Third's Charm
- it's ok
- Beautiful...Garbage
- something new
- More competent pop-rock
- A Crippling Blow For A Great Band: Near-Britney Nonsense.
- Garbage pulls it off once again!
- AMAZING
- Garbage That Grows On You
- Okay, this Garbage ain't Garbage
- title just about sums it up
- In Rapture....
- The title says it all
- This ain't no Garbage!
- "garbage" indeed
- What's the big deal?
- Brilliant!!!
- It's very good!
- MOST ACCURATE GARBAGE REVIEW
- Anything But Garbage
- Way underrated.
- New style but more honest lyrics.
- Wonderful album/Huge step for the band.Shirley is immaculate
- Deeper than one might imagine
- Different, not in a bad way, just... different
- Absolutely Wonderful!
- Garbage gone pop? Oh no!
- Definitely one of the best of 2001.
- Bwah!!!! The horror, the horror!
- What the...
- Actually more like a 3 1/2, maybe a 4 just for "Parade"...
- Just o.k.
- The worst Garbage album, still great
- Beautifulgarbagebeautiful
- Big fan from their home town!!!
- stuck somewhere between great and [uninteresting]
- Frustrating!
- Not my cup of tea
- all over the place
- Big Dissapointment
- This band should change its name...
- This Is Beautiful Garbage
- Go baby, we're right behind you baby...
- Garbage Indeed
- Not Great
- Garbage gets better and better
- People, people, PEOPLE!!
- And now for something completely different...
- To borrow from Pearl Jam: it's evolution, baby.
- Great job!
- Garbage ROCKS!
- Garbage is pretty kick [butt].