A Pretty Good Genesis Album

Review Score: (8/10)
The ratio of good to bad on this album is better than any other post-Gabriel, making it my favorite. "Who Dunnit?" sounds like the band was intentionally *trying* to do a horrible song (and they succeed), and "Another Record" sounds like a good song trapped in a mediocre performance. The rest of the album ranges from pretty good ("No Reply at All" is awfully poppy but not bad, "Me & Sarah Jane" takes a while to get me interested but it does) to very good. "Keep It Dark" (which took me some time to understand) and "Like It or Not" remain my favorite tracks. "Dodo/Lurker" doesn't bore me as much as Genesis' other late-period "epic" songs - I think because there are enough hooks to keep me entertained. Not essential by any means, but a pretty good listen.

More Reviews:

• What if you like Pete AND Phil?
• 4.5 stars, ABACAB!
• brilliant as usual--where the "new" Genesis truly arrived
• Mediocre at best..
• from brainy progressive to hip popsters
• Progressive/Pop Mix - but not Genesis' best on either side
• Abacab
• Prog rock turns prog pop, trimming off the fat!
• Genesis...grand no more...
• Pathetic release from a formerly great band
• Genesis? I just like good music
• Bad cd.... very bad!!!!!!!!!
• Fantastic Album! 5 stars isn't enough!
• Great Job Amazon!
• highly recommended
• Best three piece era Genesis album
• Genesis' creativity lurks in Abacab
• Does not cut it
• Finding new ways to shine
• Brand new ideas mixed into one release
• There's no time for good music. It remains unforgettable!
• Wonderfull classic!!
• Genesis reinventing themselves
• For ME it IS A CLASSIC OF A MILLION STARS!!! Period.
• Get your facts straight
• Trying to reach a middle ground
• You guys are vicious! Calm down for a minute..
• Jeez, do you ever give up?
• Time to get with it
• A group of artists finally finds it's footing.
• Open up
• Abacab isn't "new"?
• I think we know who the real poser is.
• Great music!!
• The Best Genesis Album
• An underrated masterpiece of experimental pop
• Good, not great
• just.....just....not good.
• Much better than I used to think
• "Tears of joy and mocking laughter, words lost in the wind"
• Simply awful considering what they once were...
• Will somebody tell me what Abacab is?????????
• One of a kind
• Dodo riddle
• Like it or not...they have a lot to say
• They are only in it for the money.
• I love this CD
• 20+ year old sound that still sounds fresh, and vibrant.
• AbAcAb
• Genesis revitalizes with clean new sound
• Genesis revitalizes with a clean new sound
• Unlike anything they've done before or since
• SELL OUT
• Genesis Evolves
• Genesis Rock, And Here's The Proof!
• Great CD for 1 song
• A Must-Have Genesis Tour de Force
• And now for something completely different....
• Who Dunnit? Genesis murdered the spirit of Gabriel!
• the buck stops here
• A Genesis New Wave Album? Well,Sort Of
• Band on the corner
• The dawn of 'new' Genesis
• Collins comes to the fore....
• The Dawn Of A New Era
• One of the Best 80s Era Genesis You Can Buy!
• WRONG DIRECTION
• Great Muzak
• not bad, I suppose
• A nice blend of musical styles
• The Absolute Best
• Am I alone?
• Nothing wrong with being POP Rock
• Genesis's pop masterpiece
• Terrific rock from Genesis
• The Best Pop Genesis That Money Can Buy
• An enjoyable pic 'n' mix of styles
• An enjoyable pick 'n' mix of styles
• Why Abacab?
• Genesis at both their best and their worst
• See? Dinosaurs _can_ evolve!
• Not bad, just ... borring.
• Always There
• What a surprise!
• Absolutely captivating!
• great album, great band
• Genesis throws a curve
• Best Album from Genesis ever
• Don't put Another Record on!
• The album that made me stop buying Genesis albums
• Another great CD from one of the all-time great bands
• Fatastic
• This album really rocks