If "Harvest Moon" was the sequel to "Harvest"...

Review Score: (6/10)
...then this album is the sequel to "Comes a Time". Like that album, this one is filled with well-played well-written but not particularly memorable music. Maybe some of it will grow on me as time goes on the way stuff from "Comes a Time" did, but Young doesn't usually work that way with me. His stuff, be it the pastoral Neil or the "grunge senior" Neil, grabs me at first listen. None of this material does, unfortunately. Plus, this album breaks a string of hourlong albums at its vinyl LP length of about 40 minutes. Could that mean his creative well is running dry? I sure hope not--I've spent half my life convincing people that this dude with the whiny voice and mediocre guitar playing is really a superlative musician. I'd like to keep on doing so.

More Reviews:

• An understated, powerful cd
• SUPERB GOLDEN FOLK CD
• Pleasant but Forgettable
• Simple Neil.
• One of his best
• prime acoustic neil
• Distant Camera
• NEIL'S WARMEST, GENTLEST ALBUM
• Nice, pleasant record
• Perfect
• Silver and Gold
• Warm and Down to Earth
• stunningly simple and nice folk music
• Neil Young at his homely best
• Get to know Neil!
• Standard Fare For Young
• Listening for a keeper
• Love it
• Reflections on love
• Grows on you...
• Precious Metals
• Classic Neil
• More Silver & Gold For NY's Coffers
• A beautiful album
• NEIL
• A MAN TOO BUSY
• Neil on heavy medication
• Silver $ Gold
• Boring
• OK-it's not rock but does it have to be?
• Great from one of the greats
• somewhat disappointing, from a master of rock
• A tunnel of light...
• Neil's gentler side
• The Best Neil album since Harvest Moon
• Speachless
• Neil is just too happy.
• What's better than silver and gold?
• My new favorite Young album
• One of his very best mellow albums
• oh dear
• What happened Neil? Did you lose a bet?
• Classic Neil at his mellowest
• Neil Young's best album in years
• If you like "Harvest" and "Harvest Moon"...
• Beautiful
• Young's Feelin' Good
• a grate album from a grate artist
• best Neil Young ever
• So uplifting, it made me sad
• It takes hold slowly
• Silver and Gold . . . Rusted?
• a low key masterpiece sure to be underappreciated
• Wonderful music, just too short.
• Neil Young - Easy Listening
• Oh so quiet...
• This album's a pleasure
• Upon reflection -- a great album
• My software's not compatible with you?
• Still got it after all these years
• A new classic!
• ho hum.......
• Golden Album
• Good old Neil, thanks God, You're still the same!
• Is'nt it better to burn out than fade away?
• Who is this and what did they do with the real Neil?
• RE/The Great Divide "cd too short controversy..."
• Returning to his roots with rewarding success .
• Good to see you, good to hear you again!
• His best since Harvest Moon
• Sleep Subsitute
• A pleasant return to his 70s sound
• did it again
• One of Neils finest
• "All I want is a song of love"
• Neil Young has completely touched my life, I weep with joy.
• "Hey Joe, this is gonna be your new favorite cd..."
• Silver and Gold will touch the souls of human beings.
• THE GREAT DIVIDE.
• Silver and Gold Is Best Neil Record Since Rust Never Sleeps
• Better than Silver and Gold
• Best yet from Mr. Young
• The king of rock-n-roll?
• This Is The Real Stuff
• A quieter Neil Young packs a punch!
• All he's got for you are pretty songs that cut clean through
• The best album Neil Young has made in a long time
• I miss the edgy melancholy
• On second thoughts.....
• so so
• Awesome
• the art of artlessness
• Outstanding!
• eh...
• silver and gold
• Neil Is Back
• Everybody knows this is Nowhere
• high praise for a great effort
• Twenty Year Journey Though the Past
• Disappointed fan.