Only for the obsessed

Review Score: (4/10)
Don't get me wrong; I love Nirvana. I also love box sets with lots of B-sides, live cuts and rarities. However, this one is scraping the bottom of the barrel. There's a reason tracks are called "rehearsals" or "demos". Often, some demos are diamonds in the rough. Unfortunately, this box set has only a handful, and for the total amount of material, it's just not worth it. Most of this should have been left on the cutting room floor.

More Reviews:

• Kurt's musical genius is proven yet again!!!
• Could've been much better
• SUCKED BOX SET EVER MADE BY GEFFEN
• Correction: The worst boxset of all boxsets
• Nirvana's Work Shines Almost 11 Years After
• A raw strip of heaven in a box...
• If you are a Nirvana fan, you cannot pass this up
• The Box Sets Of All Box Sets
• A masterpiece for all fans
• some insight
• dont expect me to cry
• For true fans and the curious fans
• finally
• completely, amazingly, awesomely, out-of-this-world
• Good for curiosity
• For the fans
• Oustanding for the Nirvana fan
• Raw Nirvana
• Need to buy something from 2004? DON'T make it this album
• An Abomination
• Very good box set
• very disappointed with this well talked about release
• lights on or off, this one is for the real fans
• Tasteful, brilliant, and essential.
• It's all here...except for....
• Any new Nirvana is a good thing
• What true fans have been longing for
• All the reviewers will eat it up if it's packaged properly
• nirvana"s child
• More something to HAVE, than something to listen to
• Interesting but not worth 5 stars
• Nirvana is the best band ever!!!...
• True Fans Only
• worth the money
• just how kurt wanted it
• Kurt undead!Kurt for ever!!
• Whiners whom were one of eMptyTV's *******
• Kurt Cobain was a Genius, Nirvana is the best band ever
• Thank you, Krist, Dave & Kurt!!!
• it's about time
• Here we are now, entertain us!!!!
• We deserve better than this bottom-of-the-barrel cop out
• Suck on this, Geffen/Interscope
• Nirvana - The most overrated band ever?
• 10 years later...
• Serious Fans Only
• With The Lights Out shows the lights aren't completely out
• "With the Lights Out" is a great purchase for Nirvana fans.
• Oh, the omissions
• A very good purchase for Nirvana fans.
• Where's the house party footage we were promised?
• Great disc, I wish more bands did something similar.
• THE GENESIS OF THE MOST INFLUENTIAL BAND OF THE 1990'S
• Kurt Cobain was a Genius, Nirvana is the best band ever
• they should put 6 hour audio dvd's 4 hour video dvd's
• Things you should know about this box set.
• Stop.
• A best of cd/dvd with it would have been nice.
• But son! what if this band nirvana makes me sick if i listen
• To all fans
• great if you can see the purpose
• No rocking out with the lights out...
• For the Hardcore Fans
• Absolutely wonderful.
• Buried Treasure
• Quick and simple review.
• one last visit to Seattle is all you'll need
• Opinion
• Not JUST for completists
• 1 OF MY FAVORITE BANDS
• NIRVANA=ONE GREAT BAND
• rape me again
• good for what it's worth
• aimed at collectors
• Great but with serious flaws
• With The Lights Out [3CD Box Set + DVD]
• NIRVANA AT ITS RAWEST
• Best value for your Nirvana collection money
• Don't listen to the naysayers - this set is amazing
• This is exactly what they promised fans
• I like it.
• Good, but it's missing ONE song!
• the perfect christmas gift
• "Do Re Mi" alone is worth the entire set...
• not worth the price
• Buy Another Boxset
• must have
• A complete mess, stick with the boots...
• May Kurt take his revenge on his former bandmates for this
• Cobain ...VIVE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
• Speechless
• Glorious Piece Of Rock "N" Roll History!!!!
• ok....too many demos
• Too much low quality trash
• Disappointment of the Year
• Kurt Cobain was a Genius, Nirvana is the best band ever
• LISTEN TO MY ALTERNATIVE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
• Excellent music, poor sound quality
• At least two discs are defective. Buy at own risk
• NIRVANA'S BEST CD, BUT NOT FOR EVERYONE