Bloated
Review Score: 








(6/10)
The main thing that killed this album is that there are decent four-minute pop songs concealed in an average of 6 and sometimes even 9 minutes of repetition. It's unfortunate that the cocaine got to the entire band so much that they didn't bother to edit the album into the magnificent follow-up to "Morning Glory" that was waiting to burst out.
There are massive guitars on all of these guitars, a huge wall of sound that sounds great nice and loud. Unfortunately, Oasis got too laid back and took their sweet time with nearly all of these songs. Not that they've ever done a fast three minute rocker, but a lot of these songs would have sounded much better in that fashion.
D'You Know What I Mean?: almost eight minutes of huge guitars and arrogant lyrics, great opener. A+
My Big Mouth: a roaring rocker, hilariously over-the-top lyrics. A
Magic Pie: the melody is brilliant, could have been so much better minus about three minutes. B+
Stand By Me: not the Ben King classic, but a great song nonetheless. A-
I Hope, I Think, I Know: more arrogant lyrics, and a lenght that begs editing. B+
The Girl in the Dirty Shoes: could have been SO good with a shorter ending!! this way, just merely good. A-
Fade In-Out: Johnny Depp drops by and lays down a competent slide guitar. menacing good song, but again, way too long. B+
Don't Go Away: classic Oasis, great song altogether, and a lenght that fits. A
Be Here Now: *sigh* more editing...this is getting boring. A-
All Around the World: if you're gonna try to do another "Hey Jude" at least have a brilliant outro. good song, decent outro, but waaaay too long. A-
It's Getting Better (Man!!): not really. a song this anthemic cannot trudge for seven minutes. B+
All Around the World (Reprise): aww heck, let's stretch the song to eleven total minutes. B-
I think it's a genuine shame that these songs are so bloated, because there's real good songs getting dragged down in their lenght: four seven-minute songs and one nine-minutes, this album just goes on too long and killed Oasis' megastardom. Of course, the anticipation for this album was deafening: you were expecting Jesus himself to show up in London on August 26 to pick up the album. There is no excusing the absurd lenght, especially after the lean and mean 50 minutes of "Morning Glory". I am willing to bet that had this album been about 20 minutes shorter, it would be much more acclaimed. Terrible shame, I'd love to see a sober version of it.
More Reviews:
- Essential Oasis
- Bollocks really
- Enourmously ......loud and bloated.
- "Be Here Now"
- The most horrendously underated rock album in history!
- Oasis defines themselves
- Why does Noel hate this so much?
- 5 Stars in its own right
- Underated
- An underated masterpiece
- better than most people think
- Not Bad
- Pure rock and roll
- This is what beatles sounded when they were stoned
- It Rocks, Its sounds awesome at times, but overall its......
- Oasis Get Bigger...
- Be - Ware Now
- An epic journey with the amps cranked to the max...
- A Disappointing Follow-Up
- Oasis gives birth to a monster
- Excellent.
- Great
- Bombastic!!!
- You see me...
- Pick it up
- This album is severly underrated
- Great rock record
- Best CD for those new to Oasis
- amazing, probably the best oasis album
- fade-in out
- OK by Oasis Standards and Still Better Then Anyone Else
- Don't listen to criticism, listen to this great album!
- 4 stars for an album worthy of it.
- It's Gettin' Better, D'You Know What I Mean?
- It gets old fast
- Glad I Just Happened To Pick It Up
- Magic trip.
- While it is not their Best, it is my Favorite
- Be Here Now - Great, but not so great as the Prequels
- Over-produced yet under-rated
- not planning on buying this cd...read this
- It's a cup of tea
- Oasis Be Here in 1967
- I was quite impressed
- a great and powerfull cd
- After conquering the world, Oasis' creative mirage runs dry
- [****] the critics!
- As Good As Anything They've Done!
- Very Underrated
- High on fame
- Criminally underrated...
- Underated album, probably my favorite Oasis cd
- A good one from the top
- Overbloated Masterpiece
- DREADFUL!!!!!!
- An album I would love to hate..but just can't
- Attains total heaviosity
- Everybody missed on this one.
- A disastrous comedown
- Wake Me Up Please...
- Overhyped, d'you know what I mean?
- band worship is sometimes blinding....
- Brilliant....but Oasis have done better
- Be Here Now- and while yer there, buy the record
- One of their best!
- By the Way...
- THE GREATEST
- The Last Mod Great Album... ; Desert Isle Oasis!!!...
- The Last Good Oasis Record
- "the BEST OASIS album of all times"
- Over-criticized
- Diamonds in the rough.
- Very disappointing
- Not Great
- Second best by Oasis
- Epic Proportions
- Oasis - don't go away
- Although Highly Criticized, BHN is a Masterpiece
- Maybe not Oasis' best but still way good
- My Favourite Oasis Album
- Fade the songs!
- When will the revisionist slagging end?
- Only Mediocre By Oasis Standards
- Average Work From A Great Band
- Oasis second best album.
- Be Here Now
- Oasis on top of the world
- Not a great album, not a horrible album.
- I don't know what they mean....
- The end of an era
- Why Do People Hate This CD So Much?
- Oasis worst album
- Underrated
- so-so
- Best Oasis album so far...
- Oasis scores a 10 with Rock/Psychadellic experiment
- Despues del Exito: un Gran Disco !
- 3 - 3 1/2 stars: Not Bad
- At Their Best
- fantastic--& NOT overproduced