One track short of 5 stars

Review Score: (8/10)
Obviously, everyone knows that "In Your Eyes" was a serious omission from this otherwise great collection. Few "best of" compilations include all desired tracks for everyone, but to leave off an artist's most famous song seems a bit over the top. No worries--the "So" album is more than worth owning. Ironically, five other songs off of that album are included on this collection.

Nonetheless, this disk is a joy to listen to for casual and serious Peter Gabriel fans alike. To this day, I love his first solo hit "Salsbury Hill", a mid-tempo track with an anthemic feel. Slow tracks such as "I Don't Remember", "Mercy Street", and "Don't Give Up" all have a mystical feel to them that can send a shiver up my spine. And for sure, the uptempo tracks like "Games Without Frontiers", "Shock The Monkey", "Sledgehammer", and "Big Time" are all very fun to listen to.

This collection just takes you on a varied and interesting musical ride. Peter's often-understated vocals and distinct musicianship make his music a refreshingly different listen compared to most rock artists. Except for the one glaring omission, this collection is a fine summary of the varied styles of this unique artist.

More Reviews:

• Pumped to Please
• Good in the car
• For the passing fan, get 'Hit' instead
• better than the new greatest hits
• Almost as good as his 2-disc collection.
• Nice compilation
• Great Gabriel Collection
• Turn Up The Voice
• Flaws are Noticable, But Still an Entertaining Retrospecitve
• A portrait of Gabriel's solo career
• True audiophile sound.
• Missing an important song
• a must have
• Only sixteen greats?
• Why no "In Your Eyes"? Well...
• Unbelievably great CD!
• a solid heads up to you, the consumer
• Sounds much better remastered
• Only for the most casual fans (and, ironically, completists)
• Lots of treasures grow on this tree
• Great Place to Start
• Has Some Minor Flaws But It's Still Magnificent!
• This Is The Picture.
• Shaking The Tree / A great ethnic piece...
• Where the HELL is 'In Your Eyes'
• Not bad.
• A Great Retrospective -- well worth it.
• Gabriel's Best on one CD
• Fairly Accurate Solo Career Representation
• A Nice Starting Place
• Essential Listening
• Sixteen of Peter Gabriels's Seventeen Golden Greats
• Peter Gabriel on a Budget
• Good, but not the best way to sum up Gabriel's career
• Good anthology album
• I like about half the songs on this one.
• Not a "Greatest Hits" Compilation
• INCREDIBLE
• Only if you already know you love Peter Gabriel!
• Absolutely essential listening
• It sure was a good decision to buy this one!
• Too Many Unlistenable Songs
• Better than So
• Shaking The Tree: Sixteen Golden Greats
• This album is a satisfactory.
• Start With This One
• Almost perfect..
• Very Good Collection
• Good Stuff!
• Peter Gabriel is a musical god
• Great Collection, but why leave out "In Your Eyes"?
• Good representation of Peter's albums
• If you're looking for an overview of Gabriel, start here.
• A great compilation from a long career.
• A summation of greatness
• Excellent Peter Gabriel
• Great, all the good ones
• Great CD