Surprisingly Reasonable Though Lacking

Review Score: (8/10)
I bought this album recently after reading some of the reviews posted here. I just had to find out for myself about this album since I've enjoyed most of the music from the Waters era of Floyd and was curious about the Gilmore incarnation of the band. Truthfully, this album would be considered a very good David Gilmore solo album, but because it bears the Floyd moniker I couldn't help but notice how some of the mediocre tracks ("Dogs of War", "One Slip", and "Yet Another Movie") could have benefited from Roger Waters' more poetic lyrics. That having been said, there are some rather outstanding songs on this album including "On Turning Away," "Learning to Fly" and "Sorrow." Thus, this album is not as horrible as some would make it out to be. I get the feeling that Gilmore was trying too hard find the right balance between his own style of songwriting and that of classic Floyd. The result is a somewhat flawed but listenable album. Even the tiresome "New Machine," "Terminal Frost," New Machine 2" medley manages to have some barely entertaining moments that might prevent one from skipping to "Sorrow." The album does have its frustrating moments, but it is worth a listen. Whether or not it's worth repeated listening is somewhat debatable. I for one will have to see how much it grows on me.

More Reviews:

• A childhood classic
• Pink Floyd proves there is life after Roger Waters
• a catocalismic fall into the abyss
• Floyd-Pop
• Pink Floyd's black eye
• A Momentary Lapse of Reason
• A Momentary Lapse of Reason, good with the bad!
• There's Much to Learn!
• Not the best, but also not held down by Waters.
• This is one of the best albums....
• This would be amusing if it weren't the Floyd
• A Momentary Lapse of Excellence...
• Still Floyd, still good
• A Definitely Awesome Album
• On the turning away
• Admit it. You miss Roger.
• The grand return of Pink Floyd
• Pink Floyd's Instrumental Cold War
• a disappointing album.
• Ethereal
• The grand return of Pink Floyd
• Roger Waters? Syd Barrett?
• This album gets far too little love
• Pink Fraud
• Reality Check
• Melodies Without a Soul
• learning to Fly
• Is this a joke?
• Nothing momentary about it
• 3 stars for money available to spend recording
• The title is quite fitting
• It grows on you a bit
• It has not aged well
• A prog rock masterpiece to be detailed with headphones
• Strange...yet it feels so...unique.
• It's pretty good, but may not be what is expected
• BY THE WAY, WHICH ONE IS PINK?
• They tried their best, I think.
• A matter of perspective.
• Lapse of theme and motivation
• Vastly Underrated
• A very fitting title
• Cesspool of [poo]
• Tasty sandwich with a huge slice of Gilmour....
• Pink Floyd pulls through hard times
• Better than some . . .
• First Floyd experience...
• Gilmore Pulls Off a Great Album, Sans Waters
• Sorry
• their best since dark side of the moon
• Momentary Lapse of Great Music
• Should have been a David Gilmour album.
• Much deeper than what people thinks
• Let's face it...
• Solid
• YES! this is a PINK FLOYD ALBUM!!!!
• Great CD
• The Rebirth Of Pink Floyd
• Very Dull
• Gilmour followed perfectly
• Good for track 2
• Unlike most Pink Floyd, This one is Uninspiring.
• Mostly a Gilmour solo like effort. But still worth it.
• Actually not that bad
• One Of My Favorite Floyd CD's
• Underrated but "A" Material By Far
• No where near Pink Floyd
• The first post-Waters Floyd is magnificent
• "Fink Floyd"
• Disappointing
• Underappreciated and Given a Bad Rap by PF Elitists
• A 'Lapse' In Quality, But Still a Mixed Blessing
• It's good but...
• Not bad
• pink floyd try to be mysterioso!!
• The Lighter Side of the Moon
• chris
• Pink Floyd? Where?
• Polly puts Roger to shame
• Very Good
• By the Way, Which One's Pink?
• Perhaps Pink Floyd's most underrated album!
• A Decent Gilmore Solo Effort
• Very Good Gilmour Solo Album
• A rock classic
• If only there were Negative Stars....
• really good
• Another "solo" Floyd album
• decent, says one with an unbiased eye.
• a beautiful album
• Lapsed Floyd
• One of Floyd's Finest
• ATMOSPHERIC AND IT ROCKS
• Gilmour and company indulge in a putrid 80s sound
• a momentary lapse of ego
• Ambient Rock At Its Finest
• Very good flow
• Should have been a Dave Gimour solo record
• No Dark Side of the Moon
• The 1st half is okay, but the 2nd has nothing 2 do with PF