Gilmour Vs. Waters?

Review Score: (10/10)
I am really surprised that apparent music lovers are subjecting this CD to a pi**ing contest. Roger Waters was a good musician and great lyricist. However, he was also this egotistical fool that wanted Pink Floyd to disband when he decided to quit!

From that perspective, I admire Gilmour for having stepped forward and continued the true PF tradition of creating original and inspiring music. This is a great CD where the band broke free from Waters' dictatorship and proved there was more to PF than Waters' interpretation of music. All music lovers like this music compilation for what it is. Its because of Waters junkies that Gilmour was not as successful as he deserved to be.

Open your mind and enjoy good tunes rather than be suckered by Roger Waters' tirade against the band because they dared to stick around after he burnt out. Keep in mind that a good musician always has their own stamp on their creation. Gilmour created his own distinctive style of music in this album and proved his versatility.

More Reviews:

• Don't forget about Gilmour!!
• MY FIRST PINK FLOYD ALBUM
• floyd with jazz and sickness of the soul
• a dreams dream
• A Decent Pink Floyd CD
• Division Bell a great album to leave with
• Strong piano-driven effort.
• Solid
• Dehydrated Floyd blessedly bereft of Roger's drama-queenism
• Bells Form Hell
• The BEST of all...
• "The Division Bell" 10 Years Later.
• By Far, The Best Pink Floyd Ever!
• solid pink floyd
• Surpasses its predecessor
• Well, It's Much Better Than "A Momentary Lapse".......
• a masterpiece
• floyds final triumph
• What's in a name?
• a classic
• floyd's finest hour
• What is this
• This is not pink floyd
• a floydian masterpiece
• five stars as always
• The triumphant comeback of Pink Floyd ten years on
• Buy This Album, The One Star Voters Are Cheats
• yes
• HIGHLY RECOMMENDED
• pink floyd's last masterpiece
• One of the band's better efforts
• a masterpiece
• The triumphant return of Pink Floyd ten years on
• The Ring of Truth
• ITS JUST NOT THE SAME!!!!
• Ah, Yes, The Post-Waters Prejudice
• Still great after all these years
• Nice mellow stuff
• Perfection !!!
• The Best Floyd
• Hugely Underrated
• the greatest cd ever
• Above average, but not Pink Floyd's best album
• Pure good music
• Still good
• A stunning musical masterpiece
• All Floyd Fans Should Open Their Eyes
• Momentary Lapse of Reason Part 2
• Yawn! Wake me when it is over
• What a wonderful album...
• The Floyd at their best!!
• Without Direction and Vision
• Not what you think
• The Division Bell
• By far, the best since Dark Side.
• Nice gem!
• Great for just listening to, and great to dig deeper too.
• THE DIVISION BELL IS FANTASTIC!!!!
• This Rocks
• CD is the ultimate chill cd
• Great surprise
• A feather through summer's wind
• Excellent
• Good CD
• Pink Floyd as good as ever!
• I Had High Hopes
• Seen for what it IS--beautiful work by the Floyd Three
• Very good stuff
• Nice
• Pink Floyd got back on track.....
• Overlooked Floyd Classic
• A Division Mott
• The best Post-Waters Floyd Album!
• a decent swan song
• the only person you ever need to know
• Ultimate Pink Floyd
• Horrifically overrated!
• A Must Have for any collection
• Useless
• Best album ever!?
• One of the best
• Divison of Floyd
• Could have been better
• Rate it for what it is.........
• Roger Who ? ? ?
• Ah, yes, the Post-Waters Prejudice
• Great!!
• AMAZING
• Unappreciated
• Should've quit in '83
• The Best of the Remaining Three
• The Final Chapter For Pink Floyd?
• To Communicate, Not Innovate
• What would be the last, turned into the best
• Let's say a Four-point-Five
• 5th best Pink Floyd album.
• A bit different than I have heard....
• The dullest album in the 'Floyd calalogue
• Thanks Barry
• The bell never tolls for these giants of myth and metaphor