Much hyped early album, but does anyone really enjoy it?

Review Score: (6/10)
There seems to be a lot of nostalgia for this the early works of Pink Floyd. Piper of the Gates of Dawn is really Syd Barrett's vision, and a psychedelic one at that. There is a lot of nonsense written about this guy in the music press. The reality is he was too unstable, and was simply replaced by Dave Gilmour, and the creative force behind the band became his partnership with Roger Waters. They went on to produce some great records: Dark Side of the Moon and Wish You Were Here. For me they started to get repetitive at The Wall, and later albums lack the quality that was present in the 70s. Forget the 60s offerings, Piper is a lukewarm interesting album, but really only for those who want every album Floyd ever produced. If you buy this expecting a forgotten masterpiece you will be disappointed. Just being honest!

More Reviews:

• The birth of Pink Floyd almost 40 years on
• Strange, yes. Great, oh yes
• not there best not there worst.
• I Can't Explain Who Good Is This
• Best album ever
• great album
• Intellectual Prog-Rockers
• ACID ON VINYL....
• Piper at the Gates of Genius
• Good Album, but
• Piper at the gates of Dawn, a great start to pink floyd!
• Psychadelic
• The crazy diamond shines
• A Great Debut - A Great Band
• Only Pink Floyd Worth Listening
• Oh My Gosh...
• What can I possibly add
• No See Emily Play? What dope producer screwed up?
• Trippy stuff!
• Psychedelic Breakfast
• One of the landmark albums of Psychidelic Rock
• Where Pink Floyd peaked
• Their weakest album
• Excuse me!
• a fantastic debut album
• A Delicate Musical Tension
• The piper must have been smoking something funny in his pipe
• The First Floyd
• Disappointment
• Floyd's debut celebrates its 30th birthday
• The birth of Pink Floyd starts here
• great debut cd
• BEST ALBUM EVER
• VERY HIGHLY RECOMMENDED
• the greatest debut album
• There's just something really addicting about this album
• When Syd Barrett was King
• Pink Floyd's debut: The Fall of Syd Barrett
• A SUPREME FLOYDIAN DEBUT
• All I need to live is this album and a supply of bread
• GREAT DEBUT FLOYD CD
• GREAT DEBUT CD OF A GREAT ROCK BAND
• The birth of Pink Floyd 37 years on
• The birth of Pink Floyd starts here
• One of the Greates Psychadelic Rock albums
• an artist's vision
• Floyd's Greatest Moment
• Respect should be given, but....
• Awful
• Syd Barrett Shines
• The Worst Floyd Album
• not Pink Floyd
• A Great Musical Journey To The Word Of The Playful Songs
• Debut albums don't get a lot better
• cool stuff
• The best Pink Floyd album ever.
• Cant stop listening to it!
• Pink Floyd? Syd Barret
• Syd, why did you go insane?
• A great debut!!!
• The definitive psychedelic album
• This is the same band that did THE WALL?
• A fine debut
• The Best by the Best
• THE PINK FLOYD PIPER!!!!!!!
• First Rate 60s British Psychedelia
• What Was the Question?
• The Essential Pink Floyd Album
• THE BIRTH OF PINK FLOYD!!
• The difference between childish and childlike.
• Great album, unfortunetly unappriciated
• Interesting Lyrics And Music, Indeed!
• The most amazing aural escape from reality...
• When we was fab...
• An Orgasmic Psychedelic Masterpiece
• Shine on you crazy diamond
• Psychedelic!
• Overall, it's either hit or miss.
• Overall, it is mostly hit or miss.
• An Interesting Debut, Different from the Floyd We All Know
• Not Syd Barrett's Best (And Not Pink Floyd)
• One of the best listening experiences ever!
• Syd was a Genuis
• a perfect balance
• Psychedelic Masterpiece
• A reply to reviewer A.M.
• Dictionary Definition of Psychedelia
• Pink Floyd is terrible !!
• A Solid Foundation for Their Greatness
• Pink Floyd on a Dungeons and Dragons campaign
• Sorry, no
• what the...
• Something I Can't Explain
• An untamed album
• Mono Mix Superior in Nearly Every Way
• Did you really listen to Interstellar Overdrive?
• Let's see Emily play with the Gnome!
• Ba-dum, CHH CHH! Ba-dum, CHH CHH!
• Psych 101
• That Cat's Something I Can't Explain...