Hagar Singing Roth Tracks? Are they out of their minds?

Review Score: (2/10)
Eddie Van Halen, although a gifted guitarist, apparently doesn't know what the fans want - a live Dave Era Album. I'm sure somewhere, deep in the 5150 vault is a screamingly, loud blast from the past. A testament to what this band used to be - the baddest band on the planet. Instead, we get badly sung versions of DLR era songs by a fat slob who obviously hates singing them.

If I wanted to hear classic VH songs butchered by an obnoxious drunk, I'd go to a kareoke bar. This album is prime example of Eddie trying to tell us what to like. Sorry Ed - I'm just not buying it, and the smart fans won't buy it either.

More Reviews:

• A Great Collection From A Great Band
• THE BEST
• Excellent Album
• Van Halen: Don't EVER Hang It Up
• A chopped off version of Finish What You Started
• Why?
• Sammy Hagar is Back!
• Anyone disrespect Van Halen is like disrespecting family!
• Last reviewer should be punished for disrespect to VH
• I don't like the music, the band, or this album
• The Ultimate and Perfect Compilation
• Van halen sucks, only good cd was VH3
• Excellent compilation!
• Bad Packaging, RIP OFF, Same old stuff nothing new, WRONG
• It's About Time!
• A casual fan's response
• Van Halen 1977-1984. R.I.P.
• 5 stars for one world 1 for the other
• the extra tracks suck!
• Good VH Release From Rhino - Minor Things Wrong
• How To Make This a TRUE VH Greatest Hits
• Who really cares??
• I only bought this for the Sammy stuff....
• best of 3 worlds...
• Sammy vs. Dave - Advantage: Sammy
• DLR Rules...
• Dis-jointed, but still a nice hard-rockin' tribute album
• I Brought My Pencil....
• In my words
• Great deal for your buck.
• The real Van Halen
• Missed Opportunity becomes cheap promotion for tour
• Very good... but it could be better.
• Love Walks OUT
• Dave Out - Sammy In - Sammy Out, In - $$$
• Dave Lee Roth IS Van Halen
• Boycott
• Learning to See
• Please, stop it. Dave is gone, and he is never coming back.
• Dave or the Grave, Baby!!!
• DAVEDAVEDAVE....What about Sammy?
• Get Dave Lee Roth back in this band ! It's not too late !
• An amazing collection!
• Will please casual and devoted fans
• AHHHHHHHHHH Finally!!!!!!!!!!
• BE AWARE!!!!!!!
• Good Stuff, just a few things missing.
• Just another collection of songs
• Where have all the good songs gone?
• Much better than the last compilation
• Why can't this be GOOD?
• It's no dam good !
• Perfect Van Halen compilation!
• It's About Time...
• Great collection of Van Halen for NEW fans.
• Good songs, but an unnecessary release
• the white is dlr and the balck hagar or vice versa
• EXCELLENT
• An Ass Kickin Album
• NOT EXACTLY THE BEST OF BOTH WORLDS
• ROTH AND ROLL
• Don't listen to the crybabies!!!
• This time they got it right! Excellent album!
• NOT A TRUE REPRESENTATION OF VH AT ALL!!
• This time they got it WRONG!
• This really is the best of both worlds
• Best of Both Worlds Rocks
• Of course, YES!
• glam metal
• Buy The Individual Albums Instead
• Will the Real VH Please Stand Up
• Best of Both Worlds
• The new tracks are nothing special.
• Get Over It
• 2 different bands...............
• Long Overdue Compilation from VH
• Rhino Records
• Nice compilation for none fans - fans don't buy it
• And Somebody said Fair Warning Lord!!!!!!!
• Music: 5 Stars. Concept & Packaging: 1 Star...
• Same Crap Again
• a definate must for any VH fan
• The soundtrack of our generation!
• Roth Fans Get Ripped Off
• So where is the Best of Volume 2?
• A great collection, perfect for new or old fans
• 5 Stars for the classics / 3 for the new songs....
• Another CRAP Van Halen Compilation.
• An Awesome piece of Rock History
• It's ok
• a great start
• Music in an artform, don't make me laugh!
• It's nice having all the "hits" in one package
• A compilation to make both die hard and casual fans mad
• Could have some more tracks on this.
• MOST REVIEWERS HERE HAVE IT ALL WRONG
• Can't Complain
• Legends Fade, but Diamonds are Forever
• Get over it!
• Can complain, this album is crap.