hmmm
Review Score: 








(8/10)
At first I was really underwhelmed by the new Wilco. I loved the first few Wilco records, they were chock full of catchy hooky songs that would stick in your head like crazy. As the band got more adventurous and experimental, culminating in Yankee Hotel Foxtrot, the hooks took a back seat to the overall sound and the process, which was okay because the sound was so overwhelmingly alien and beautiful. So on first listen, I'm struck with the same lack of obvious hooks, but also a decided absence of experimentalism. But like I said, that was on first listen. Closer inspection shows that the weird sounds and wild experimentation are still present, just sort of focused and contained within certain tracks. This record is surprisingly quiet and introspective, lots of just vocals and piano. But almost as surprising is Wilco's tendency to rock out towards the end of songs. Like Crazy Horse before them, Wilco let melancholy country ditties, build and eventually explode into a full on rock jam with wild chaotic drumming, peals of feedback and screaming guitar leads. Very exhilarating and a good balance to the minimalism of the rest of the record. The two standout tracks for those waiting for the 'weird parts' are track three, "Spiders (Kidsmoke)" which is based around a strangely proggy krautrock song structure. A definite head nodding NEU! rhythm with lots of scrabbling guitar and weird skronky atonal bleats. And there's the fifteen minute long track eleven "Less Than You Think", which is mostly a noisy, fuzzy ambient drone, equal parts feedback and what sounds like shortwave radio, building and building to an almost Merzbowian frenzy. Pretty cool. But as always, it's Tweedy's songs, that manage to shine through, no matter what sort of sonic detritus is piled atop them.
More Reviews:
- Intriguing
- Another Wilco classic
- Great Surprise... good reason to watch The Passion again
- Overrated? Wilco?? NO WAY
- yet another step up
- B O R I N G!
- Underappreciated
- Wilco Goes to the Next Level
- Wilco's best album
- Jeff Tweedy's mind--Terrible place to live,great to visit
- THE Best Album of 2004.
- 5th, 6th, 7th.....times a charm!!
- Don't expect another Yankee Hotel Foxtrot
- A Legend Is Born, Or Something Cheesy Like That....
- A downer for an otherwise good band
- Wilco's AGIB: Another ditty of a "pop" gem
- Awesome
- The Sammy Sosa of the music scene
- Another release worth a listen
- Enough with the Neil Young guitar solos
- not bad
- ... and after 3 months, 5 stars
- 6 Stars
- Best of 2004: Becomes a classic with each new listen
- Also a must, sort of...
- Subtle album that creeps up on you.
- Their weakest album
- Wilcotastic
- Wilco's best
- Jeff Tweedy Channels John Lennon!
- Very good from one of the best bands around
- Listen to this album more than once
- changing their tune
- wilco did it again and did it again they did
- this recent rash of kidsmoke
- Unpleasant.
- an egg is laid
- Great album...
- Brilliant!!!
- my favorite wilco album yet
- Music 4 1...LOUD!
- More Noise from These Boys
- Yawn
- Everything I hope for and more.
- 4 stars
- Slow, Tough Listen
- Hmmmm
- Better than expected
- b e a u t y
- Not really enhanced
- Not as good as it could have been
- Strange, but so much better than everything else out there.
- Really bad
- Not great
- Superb!
- Feedback on Feedback
- Less Than You Think
- Gets better and better with each listen
- Lets complicate the matter more!
- Why not a five?
- Another misunderstood project from a master
- Not Great, but Good
- Wilco go trippier than ever...
- Wilco Continues to Impress
- I'm Impressed
- There's a reason it's called songcraft
- experimental vs too experimental
- Fantastic!
- Get well soon, Jeff!
- If you want another YHF..thats your first problem.
- Wilco is amazing
- A great album from an immensly talented band
- A step backwards, but still a great listen
- -better- than yhf...
- Solid
- What's all the fuss about?
- lacking
- Another masterpiece
- This is a Continuation of A. Bubul's Review, Credithervotes
- Still hasn't grown on me
- I Think I'm Done with Wilco
- a classic is born
- Rocks, Rolls, Shouts, Moans...It Will Turn You
- Wilco's best so far!!!
- perfect
- Don't believe the naysayers
- Another Gem
- Wilco's best yet.
- An Album that GROWS on you
- What went wrong?
- It was inevitable.
- keep listening...
- Patient listening will be rewarded
- Buy a Wilco T-shirt Instead
- Rolling Stone told me to buy it - so I did
- Very misleading at first